Skip to the content

PA Lawsuit Asks State Supreme Court to Intervene in Redistricting

by Emily Scott, Keystone State News Connection

PA Lawsuit Asks State Supreme Court to Intervene in Redistricting

A new lawsuit asks the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to intervene in creating a new congressional district map for the Commonwealth, as concerns grow the legislature and governor will not be able to reach an agreement in time for the 2022 primary.

In the case, the Public Interest Law Center is representing leaders of Common Cause Pennsylvania, Fair Districts PA, and the League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania.

Ben Geffen, staff attorney at the Center, said the suit is about trying to avoid the mistakes of the 2011 congressional maps, which were thrown out by the state Supreme Court in 2018 due to partisan gerrymandering.

“It set a precedent, for the first time saying that it is a violation of the Pennsylvania Constitution to draw a map in order to benefit one party or another party,” Geffen explained. “It’s an opportunity for Pennsylvania to get the map right in the first instance.”

Gov. Tom Wolf sent a letter last week to the House State Government Committee, flagging his concerns with its proposed congressional map. The lawsuit was filed in Commonwealth Court.

Khalif Ali, executive director of Common Cause Pennsylvania, said they are also asking the Supreme Court to end what’s known as “prison gerrymandering,” when people in prison are counted as residents of the county where they’re incarcerated, not where they would normally vote.

Ali pointed out in Pennsylvania, this most often involves people from Philadelphia or Allegheny counties.

“It’s increasing the strength of representation in areas that, although they deserve representation, they may not deserve the type of representation that happens when there’s an increase of several thousand inmates in your county that don’t get an opportunity to really talk to a representative,” Ali stated.

The Department of State has requested the House, Senate and congressional maps be approved by Jan. 24 to meet deadlines for the May 2022 primary elections.


Una nueva demanda solicita a la Corte Suprema de Pensilvania que intervenga en la creacion de un nuevo mapa de distritos del Congreso para el Commonwealth, a medida que aumentan las preocupaciones de que la legislatura y el gobernador no podran llegar a un acuerdo a tiempo para las primarias de 2022.

En el caso, el Centro de Derecho de Interes Publico representa a los lideres de Common Cause Pennsylvania, Fair Districts P-A y la Liga de Mujeres Votantes de Pennsylvania.

Ben Geffen, del Centro, dice que se trata de evitar los errores de los mapas del Congreso de 2011, los cuales fueron descartados por la Suprema Corte del estado en 2018 debido a la manipulacion partidista.

“Sento un precedente, al decir por primera vez que es una violacion de la Constitucion de Pensilvania el dibujar un mapa para beneficiar a un partido u otro,” explica Geffen. “Pensilvania tiene la oportunidad de obtener el mapa correcto en primera instancia.”

El gobernador Tom Wolf envio una carta la semana pasada al Comite de Gobierno del Estado de la Camara, senalando las preocupaciones con su mapa del Congreso propuesto. La demanda se presento en la Corte del Commonwealth.

Khalif Ali, de Common Cause Pennsylvania, dice que tambien estan pidiendo a la Corte Suprema que se ponga fin a lo que se conoce como “manipulacion de prisiones”. Que es cuando las personas que se encuentran en prision se cuentan como residentes del condado donde estan encarcelados, y no donde normalmente votarian.

Ali dice que en Pensilvania, esto involucra con mayor frecuencia a personas de los condados de Filadelfia o Allegheny.

“Esta aumentando la fuerza de representacion en areas que, aunque lo merece, es posible que no obtengan el tipo de representacion que ocurre cuando hay un aumento de miles de reclusos en su condado que no tienen la oportunidad de hablar realmente con un representante,” asegura Ali.

El Departamento de Estado ha solicitado que los mapas de la Camara, el Senado y el Congreso sean aprobados antes del 24 de enero para cumplir con los plazos para las elecciones primarias de mayo de 2022.